Thursday, October 11, 2012

Blog 7 - Serbia and Gay Rights


Resulting in much controversy, the Serbian government recently put a ban upon a gay pride march set to be held in Belgrade this Saturday. As a result, the EU has informed the Serbian government that they must protect human rights if they still wish to join the union. The Serbian government was officially made an EU candidate in March, but this ban puts them at risk of having that candidacy revoked. Serbian Prime Minister Ivica Dacic stated that this was a security issue. In the past, protesters opposing the march clashed violently with police, so the march was banned last year as well. However, it is relatively certain that these are not the only reasons that this ban was enacted this year. Patriarch Irinej, head of the Orthodox Church, called the pride event a “parade of shame” and called on Dacic to stop it from occurring. Irinej and the Islamic Community also tried to get Dacic to ban a photo exhibition that portrayed Jesus in women's clothing and heels, but the government did not enact this and in fact, police protected the exhibition. However, because of the riots in the past, the prime minister thinks the parade would be more of a safety risk.

There is clear hypocrisy here, but while that is true, the safety concerns are also valid. However, it seems fully justified for the EU to threaten terminating the candidacy in light of this. While cultural relativism should always be kept in mind, in the terms of the EU, banning this parade is a human rights violation. Many representatives have stated this and have come out against the ban. Limiting expression of a minority, oppressed group under the pretense of safety while being influenced by religious leaders is highly suspect. Since this clearly violates the parameters of the EU's human rights requirements, they can be denied membership.

No comments: